3 Mistakes That Brought Convoy from $4 Billion to $0

Dan Lewis and Grant Goodale, the founders of Convoy, launched this company to revolutionize the freight Industry, an Industry that is largely resistant to change.

Lewis, with his background in technology and product management at companies like Google & Amazon, and Goodale, an experienced software developer, spotted a significant gap in the logistics market: the lack of efficiency and transparency.

The goal was to make trucking:

• More efficient
• Profitable for Carriers
• Cost-effective for shippers

Early on, Convoy faced challenges, The logistics sector, which is known for its reliance on conventional methods, presented a significant hurdle in terms of technology adoption and change resistance

Their strategy? show immediate ROI to customers, by reducing empty miles for carriers and lowering shipping costs for shippers.

Using real-time data and predictive analytics allowed Convoy to optimise routes, leading to cost savings and reduced environmental impact, resonating well with the growing eco-conscious market.

Go to Market Playbook:

• Branding: Convoy focused on establishing itself as a tech-savvy, efficient alternative to traditional freight logistics.
• Sustainability Focus: Convoy positioned itself as not just efficient, but also eco-friendly, reducing carbon emissions through optimised routes.
• Adoption of New Technology: The use of technologies like AI and Machine Learning appealed to modern, forward-thinking shippers and carriers.
• Innovative Features: Automated brokering and real-time pricing algorithms were industry firsts.
• Diversification: From its initial focus on local freight, Convoy expanded to offer nationwide services, significantly increasing its market reach.

Product Traction:

• Convoy achieved 98% automated load matching of all loads (true pricing, negotiation and matching in the open marketplace) via its mobile or web apps.
• Drivers used the Convoy app for every step of the job 96% of the time and on-time performance was 94% (within 30 minutes of appointment).

In the Startup world, VCs use a term called Escape Velocity, which means that the startup cannot be pulled down because of the gravitational pull of market forces. VCs started assuming that Convoy had achieved “Escape Velocity” and at this point, it was too big to fail.

Convoy attracted substantial investment from venture capitalists, drawn to its innovative business model and technology-driven approach.

Lost Focus: Prioritizing Investors Over Customers and Drivers

• In late 2021, Convoy stopped offering incentives to shippers to join its platform, because investors wanted to see better margins for the bottom line.
• Although they did increase their gross margins from 17.7% to 18.1%.
• Convoy’s commitment to maintaining high gross margins needed a shift, away from the aggressive bidding strategies that helped in its early years.
• This shift meant turning down business from shippers and forgo bidding opportunities that didn’t align with the company’s margin objectives.
• By deliberately reducing load volumes, Convoy shot itself in the face and caused a bottleneck for its own growth, a characteristic that had once been a cornerstone of its appeal to investors.
• The company banked upon sustained high margins, to attract future investment, yet it underestimated the significance of a diminishing growth narrative.

The irony is that Convoy’s actions started mirroring the classic case of an Industry that it wanted to disrupt in the first place.

Convoy’s robust data was generally credited as the driving force behind its achievements.

However, ironically, it was this very reliance on data and technology that triggered its eventual downfall.

The company’s focus on data-driven decision-making, while seemingly prudent, ultimately detracted from the agility and risk-taking that is often vital for enduring success in a growth-driven market.

3 Factors Leading to Downfall:

• Increased Competition: The entry of new players in the tech-driven logistics market eroded Convoy’s competitive advantage.
• Financial Strain: The continual need for investment in technology and market expansion, coupled with operational losses, put a significant financial strain on the company.
• Economic Shifts: Changes in the broader economic environment, such as recessions or shifts in trade policies, can significantly impact logistics operations.

Convoy competitors, ranging from traditional brokerages such as C.H. Robinson and newer players including Uber Freight, were also struggling amidst the traditional trucking market.

When the market showed no signs of improvement or relief and Convoy was bleeding $10 Million a month, its founders started looking for a suitable buyer, but after a long unsuccessful search, they decided to sell the company for parts.

That is where in a recently concluded deal, Industry rival, Flexport acquired Convoy’s technology stack, a small number of Convoy employees will also join Flexport as part of this deal.

‍